﻿<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<ArticleSet>
  <Article>
    <Journal>
      <PublisherName>Tabriz University of Medical Sciences</PublisherName>
      <JournalTitle>Journal of Caring Sciences</JournalTitle>
      <Issn>2251-9920</Issn>
      <Volume>14</Volume>
      <Issue>1</Issue>
      <PubDate PubStatus="ppublish">
        <Year>2025</Year>
        <Month>02</Month>
        <DAY>19</DAY>
      </PubDate>
    </Journal>
    <ArticleTitle>Is CONSORT a Risk of Bias Tool for Experimental Studies: A Big Misunderstanding</ArticleTitle>
    <FirstPage>1</FirstPage>
    <LastPage>4</LastPage>
    <ELocationID EIdType="doi">10.34172/jcs.025.33575</ELocationID>
    <Language>EN</Language>
    <AuthorList>
      <Author>
        <FirstName>Ehsan</FirstName>
        <LastName>Sarbazi</LastName>
        <Identifier Source="ORCID">https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8190-9942</Identifier>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName>Homayoun</FirstName>
        <LastName>Sadeghi-Bazargani</LastName>
        <Identifier Source="ORCID">https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0396-8709</Identifier>
      </Author>
    </AuthorList>
    <PublicationType>Journal Article</PublicationType>
    <ArticleIdList>
      <ArticleId IdType="doi">10.34172/jcs.025.33575</ArticleId>
    </ArticleIdList>
    <History>
      <PubDate PubStatus="received">
        <Year>2024</Year>
        <Month>06</Month>
        <Day>10</Day>
      </PubDate>
      <PubDate PubStatus="accepted">
        <Year>2024</Year>
        <Month>07</Month>
        <Day>02</Day>
      </PubDate>
    </History>
    <Abstract>Introduction: In order to avoid bias in systematic reviews (SRs), the accuracy in selection of risk of bias (RoB) assessment tools is essential to obtain highest level of evidence for evidence-based decision making in health care. We aimed to review how ‘CONSORT statement’, as a reporting quality of randomized controlled trials, has been misused in recent SRs as a ROB tool. Methods: A mini-review was performed in international databases including PubMed, Google Scholar and hand-searches for published and unpublished literature from 2000 to 2021 and written in English. The following keywords: risk of bias, "Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials", CONSORT, "systematic review" were used. Citations were screened and those meeting our inclusion criteria were retained. Results: A total of 11 SRs were identified that misused CONSORT as a ROB tool, four of which were used only CONSORT as ROB tool. Different authentic magazines from various countries were recognized. Conclusion: The CONSORT statement aims to increase clarity and consistency of transparency of reporting in randomized controlled trials. It is quite essential to draw the attention of SR researchers, journal editors/reviewers as well as the reading audience to the fact that CONSORT statement CONSORT statement is not a ROB tool.  </Abstract>
    <ObjectList>
      <Object Type="keyword">
        <Param Name="value">CONSORT</Param>
      </Object>
      <Object Type="keyword">
        <Param Name="value">Clinical trials</Param>
      </Object>
      <Object Type="keyword">
        <Param Name="value">Systematic reviews</Param>
      </Object>
      <Object Type="keyword">
        <Param Name="value">Epidemiologic methods</Param>
      </Object>
      <Object Type="keyword">
        <Param Name="value">Quality of reporting</Param>
      </Object>
    </ObjectList>
  </Article>
</ArticleSet>